newsweek eulogizes american christianity PART 1
There has been much ado about a recent issue of Newsweek which pronounced the decline of American Christianity. Conservative Christian media outlets and bloggers have taken to chastising editor Jon Meacham, dismissing the Episcopalian’s editorial treatment of a study by the American Religious Identification Survey, which cited a 10 percent drop in Americans who claim to be Christians. Rather than damning Mr. Meacham to that old Christian woodshed somewhere below the earth’s crust, why not consider the subject of the study? Though lopping off the ear of the messenger is temporarily enjoyable it is rarely fruitful. If a man has one hundred sheep and ten of them go missing, the good shepherd asks why.
Now I’d rather crank up my iPod listening to a band that sounds like Modest Mouse with positive lyrics and pretend that someone just found the LORD through a Christian t-shirt I was wearing. Avoidance is a helpful tool. The cultural version of American Christianity has been visibly suffering for two decades. Signs are everywhere. If your local Christian bookstore still exists, for example, congratulations. Pick up a pack of “Testa-mints” from the checkout area and mail them to me. For the rest of us: let’s list the why’s…
6 reasons why cultural Christianity is declining
- Cultural Christianity has easily definable enemies. The reason the Bible is so darn long, has something to do with the fact that it is an ongoing story about a God who loves his creation. Much of it deals with how followers of Christ are to treat their enemies. People who oppose school prayer. People who are pro-choice. People who are gay. People who were born in the Middle East. People who believe in evolution. Clearly enemies, right? Clearly bound for judgment and destruction, right? Love those that hate you. Bless them that curse you. Pray for those who spitefully use you and persecute you. Romans speaks of God’s kindness drawing all of us to repentance; even those of us who assume we’ve sinned a great deal less than the next guy. How does anyone learn that God is kind in a world of constant brokenness? Through grace demonstrated by others. Be slow in choosing your enemies.
- Cultural Christianity hopes for judgment. When you have a list of enemies, you must have an intended purpose for them. The book of Amos says: “Woe to you who desire the day of the LORD! Why would you have the day of the LORD? It is darkness, and not light.” God does intend to judge the righteous and the wicked. Those desiring judgment to fall quickly may find themselves in the latter group. The target audience of the Hebrew prophets was God’s chosen people, Israel. It was their culture that God detested and rejected. When the prophets of scripture spoke against Israel’s enemies, it was done in passing. “Babylon will get theirs, don’t worry about them. Vengeance belongs to someone else. What about you?” Israel was promised liberation, not victory.
- Cultural Christianity embraces escapism. Rapture theology allows Christians to say, “we”re outta here!” This theological idea is less than 200 years old and is a peculiar position in light of Jesus teaching his followers to pray that God’s kingdom would be experienced on earth. Cultural Christians live with the idea that they won’t be here for long. The bible of course tells us the exact opposite. We will be here on the earth forever as God redeems his creation and establishes a holy city on the earth. Vastly different than being given wings of ignorance and a harpsichord. Imagine eternity spent in the exact same location where you refused to love your neighbor. Not a very heavenly feeling, is it? Because Christians believe in a kingdom not built with hands that extends for eternity, we should embrace every opportunity to demonstrate that belief.
- Cultural Christianity is too political. Theologian and pop singer John Mayer asks, “Is there anyone who can remember changing their mind from some paint on a sign… or someone yelled real loud one time?” I have a friend who lives near a Planned Parenthood. When I meet up with him for morning coffee there is a group of people standing outside holding protest signs. I wonder if anyone has driven by and thought, “Gee, I guess abortion is wrong. I just changed my mind.” If anything this has an opposite effect, further strengthening the belief that Christians only care about winning a cultural battle for conservatism. Perhaps you’ve noticed that the pendulum has swung in the opposite direction recently. It’s not uncommon to hear Christians with a liberal bent berating those who are more politically conservative. “Good morning” to believers who must attach a political adjective to your Christianity, you’re actions are exactly as offensive to the other side as the actions of the other sideare to you! The tactics are the same, only the sound bites are different. The false dichotomy of American politics is being exposed, hence the tension in our country. Followers of Jesus embrace the sanctity of life, all of life, from unborn to the feudalist peasant, to the minority, to women, to the dying elderly. They recognize all injustice and work to lovingly correct it, regardless of which party claims the injustice as “their issue.”
- Cultural Christianity has a graven image problem. According to the book, unChristian, by Dave Kinnaman, the negative effects of Christian marketing are up to ten times greater than positive outcomes. If a mass mailing produces one new Christian there are ten people who have been moved further from faith in Christ. If you’re a pastor, I know what you’re thinking: “Those marketers don’t have my graphics guy! They don’t have my clever phrasing.” I know this because that’s what we all think. Mass marketing of Christianity through mailings produces one half of one percent return. 20 thousand fliers = 100 people who might check out the Jesus you’re selling. Potentially 1000 people who will decide to permanently ignore your message. Save your money. Forget your image. Sit down and pray with someone instead. Christians should consider prayer their greatest marketing tool. Jesus doesn’t need to be cooler. He just needs to be seen.
- Cultural Christianity “sees that hand.”I remember listening to an evangelist’s sermon when I was a kid. It ended typically, “You don’t know when the last trump will sound. With every head bowed and every eye closed… (then there was a dramatic pause)… (still pausing)…” With the church keyboard turned up to 11, the trump did sound, thanks to the keyboard player. Hearts all across the auditorium stopped beating. Old people died. Many of us were audibly impaired for about a week. Additionally there was a certain odor coming from the hind section of people’s Sunday Bests. Becoming a disciple has very little to do with a repeat-after-me-prayer. Loving one another as believers is the absolute best form of evangelism, or so taught Jesus. When Christians care for other Christians everyone notices. When we work together to make ourselves and one another look more like Christ, we’ll “see a lot more hands” in a figurative sense of course.
Within the Christian subculture opinions are flying like ravens sent from an ark. According to subculture pundits, some churches have been preaching a false gospel, some don’t talk about sin enough, some are too stuffy, some aren’t relevant, some have signs with cute slogans and some don’t. Some believe that the Newsweek article is leftist propaganda to undo Christianity. Some believe it’s a call to arms. Maybe we should say, “It is what it is.” Maybe we should notice that the article says very little about authentic Christianity; it is largely about the subculture of Christianity and its unraveling.
Missionaries take their message to the culture into which they have been called. That is, they strip themselves of the culture they know in order to present a greater message to a culture they must learn.
Grace.
Part 2 Friday: “Responding to the Eulogy.”




