immorality for upright writers
You have spent most of your life being a good person, and that is nice. Me too. I used to be (ahem) clergy, so I know what it means to be impressively good (at least, as far as anyone else knows).
Every writer fights her internal editor. My internal editor is Sybil. He has at least 57 distinct personalities, all of them very upright and well-dressed. Many of them suffer from male pattern baldness, but that is beside the point. My IE takes on the look and attitude of real people I know and says to me: “If you write that what will these other upstanding citizens in your head think of you? They’ll probably think you’re dirty or some sort of scoundrel. Write something pretty.”
Am I alone here?
I wrote myself a note in the fancy-fancy notebook as a warm-up exercise. It is to me, but I’ll share it with those of you who are denizens of decency by day and writers by night:
“Within the first book of the bible there is murder, incest, rape, polygamy, drunken debauchery, war, oppression, sodomy, racism, greed, arrogance, and piles of men who are described as having “known his wife.”
There are enough Christian books about some beautiful Amish prude, whose husband is tender, sexless and hard-working, whose beard feels bristly across her makeupless-face. There are enough Christian paintings of churches in dark vales lit with an interior incandescent bulb providing light for the rest of nature, which must include a deer who is panteth-ing for water.
God is not in the business of redeeming the ideal. Redeem a rape, something horrible. Maybe it’s as simple as living to tell about it. That is a God universally believable. All of this other perfectionism is an expression of the wild religious ego; a false, impenitent self, hiding behind knit-together fig leaves. In your work, give God a moment where he must forsake Christ on the cross because of the sin of your characters, otherwise you are not an artist, and probably not a Christian.
Don’t write a Christian story. Write a good story instead.”






